Should your company report under CSRD or voluntary standards?
Whether your company must report under CSRD or can choose a voluntary standard depends primarily on your size, structure, and EU market presence. Large EU-based companies and certain non-EU multinationals operating in Europe face a legal obligation under the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive. Smaller or out-of-scope companies retain flexibility but may still find voluntary reporting strategically valuable.
In this article, we address the most common questions around CSRD compliance, voluntary frameworks, and how to choose the right path for your organisation.
Which companies are legally required to report under CSRD?
CSRD reporting is legally required for large EU companies, listed SMEs on EU-regulated markets, and non-EU parent companies with significant EU revenues. Specifically, a company falls within scope if it meets at least two of three criteria: more than 250 employees, annual turnover above EUR 40 million, or a balance sheet total above EUR 20 million. Non-EU companies with EU net turnover exceeding EUR 150 million are also captured.
The rollout is phased. Large public-interest entities with more than 500 employees were first required to report for financial year 2024. Other large companies meeting the two-out-of-three threshold follow for financial year 2025, with reports due in 2026. Listed SMEs and certain non-EU companies face later deadlines, though some exemptions and opt-outs apply depending on jurisdiction and group structure.
Companies that are subsidiaries of a group already reporting at the consolidated level may qualify for an exemption, provided the parent’s consolidated sustainability report covers them. This exemption is not automatic and requires meeting specific conditions set out in the directive, so legal review is advisable before assuming it applies.
What voluntary sustainability frameworks exist outside CSRD?
Outside CSRD, the most widely used voluntary sustainability frameworks are the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI standards), the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) standards, and the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) framework. Each serves a different primary audience and purpose, from broad stakeholder transparency to investor-focused climate risk disclosure.
GRI standards are the most globally adopted voluntary framework and cover a broad range of environmental, social, and governance topics. They are topic-based and modular, allowing companies to report on what is most material to their operations. SASB standards, now integrated into the IFRS Foundation’s work through the ISSB, are more sector-specific and oriented toward financial materiality for investors.
The TCFD framework focuses specifically on climate-related risks and opportunities and has been widely adopted by financial institutions and large corporates. Many jurisdictions have also begun incorporating TCFD-aligned disclosures into regulatory requirements, meaning the line between voluntary and mandatory is blurring in this space. The ISSB’s IFRS S1 and S2 standards, published in 2023, are increasingly being adopted by countries outside the EU as their baseline sustainability disclosure requirement.
How does CSRD differ from voluntary ESG reporting standards?
The core difference between CSRD and voluntary ESG reporting standards is legal obligation and standardisation. CSRD mandates reporting using the European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS), requires third-party assurance, and integrates sustainability disclosures into the statutory management report. Voluntary frameworks allow companies to select topics, depth, and format based on their own materiality judgments and stakeholder expectations.
ESRS under CSRD apply a double materiality perspective, meaning companies must assess both how sustainability issues affect their business (financial materiality) and how their business affects people and the environment (impact materiality). Most voluntary frameworks focus primarily on one dimension. GRI, for example, emphasises impact materiality, while SASB and TCFD lean toward financial materiality for investors.
CSRD also requires limited assurance from an independent auditor, moving sustainability reporting closer to the rigour of financial reporting. Voluntary frameworks carry no such requirement, though some companies choose to seek external assurance to strengthen credibility. The consequence of this difference is significant: CSRD-compliant reports face external scrutiny and carry legal weight, while voluntary reports are largely self-governed.
Should out-of-scope companies still report voluntarily?
Yes, out-of-scope companies should seriously consider voluntary sustainability reporting, particularly if they operate in the supply chains of large CSRD-obligated companies. Large companies subject to CSRD must report on their value chain, which means they will increasingly request sustainability data from their suppliers and partners regardless of whether those partners are legally required to report themselves.
Beyond supply chain pressure, voluntary reporting builds internal discipline. Collecting and structuring ESG data requires organisations to examine their operations, governance, and risks in ways that often surface inefficiencies and opportunities. Companies that begin this process early are better positioned if regulatory scope expands or if they grow into the mandatory thresholds.
Voluntary reporting also supports access to financing. Banks, investors, and insurers are increasingly integrating ESG criteria into their assessments. A company with structured, credible sustainability disclosures is better placed to secure favourable terms than one with no documented ESG position. For growth-oriented companies, voluntary reporting can be a competitive signal, not just a compliance exercise.
What are the penalties for failing to comply with CSRD?
Penalties for failing to comply with CSRD are set at the member state level, meaning the specific consequences vary across EU countries. However, the directive requires member states to introduce effective, proportionate, and dissuasive sanctions. These can include financial penalties, public disclosure of the infringement, and, in some jurisdictions, personal liability for board members responsible for the statutory report.
Beyond formal sanctions, the reputational risk of non-compliance is substantial. CSRD reports are publicly available and auditor-assured, which means gaps or failures become visible to investors, customers, and regulators. Companies in regulated sectors, or those seeking public contracts, may face additional consequences if sustainability disclosures are absent or materially deficient.
It is worth noting that CSRD compliance failures are not treated in isolation. Sustainability reporting is increasingly linked to other regulatory frameworks, including the EU Taxonomy Regulation and the Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD). A failure to report accurately under CSRD can therefore create downstream exposure under related regulations.
How should a company choose the right reporting standard?
A company should choose its reporting standard based on three factors: legal obligation, primary audience, and operational readiness. If you are within CSRD scope, the choice is made for you: ESRS under CSRD is mandatory. If you are out of scope, the right voluntary framework depends on whether your primary audience is investors, customers, regulators, or the broader public.
- If your primary audience is investors or lenders: ISSB standards (IFRS S1 and S2) or TCFD-aligned reporting provides financially material, decision-relevant information that capital providers increasingly expect.
- If you are in a CSRD-obligated supply chain: Aligning with ESRS or the voluntary ESRS for SMEs (the VSME standard) makes it easier to respond to data requests from your customers without building a separate reporting structure.
- If you want broad stakeholder transparency: GRI standards offer the most flexible and globally recognised framework for comprehensive impact reporting across environmental, social, and governance topics.
- If you are sector-specific and investor-focused: SASB standards provide industry-level metrics that map directly to the financial risks and opportunities most relevant to your sector.
Operational readiness matters as much as audience alignment. A framework is only as useful as the data infrastructure behind it. Before committing to any standard, assess whether your current financial and operational systems can produce the required data reliably. Starting with a materiality assessment, then selecting the framework that best matches your material topics and stakeholder needs, is a more effective sequence than choosing a framework first and retrofitting your processes to it.
For companies navigating both the technical and strategic dimensions of this decision, working with advisers who combine sustainability expertise with financial and compliance knowledge can significantly reduce the risk of choosing a path that creates more reporting burden than business value. Greenstep’s sustainability services team support companies at exactly this intersection, helping organisations build reporting structures that are both credible and operationally sustainable.